Disc degeneration proved trauma induced but selfie-inflicted damage sinks eco loss claim

Goodfellow v Clarke [2015] QDC 193

A Rockhampton compensation claimant has convinced a court his degenerative disc condition – commonly thought to be age related – was as a direct result of a multi vehicle collision on the Bruce Highway near Calliope in which he was a passenger.

Council plant operator Michael Goodfellow was ambulanced to the Gladstone Hospital but the X-ray views appeared normal as did those repeated 16 months later.

However on MRI undertaken at an even later date, a minor disc bulge at C3/4 with “mild desication of the intervertebral disc” was reported.

In the subsequent injury claim, CTP insurers Suncorp and Allianz asserted – via medical specialist John Fraser – that these findings were indications of “degenerative change” notwithstanding Fraser conceded  the prospect of a male in his early 20s developing such a condition was “virtually none”.

Fellow orthopedist Cameron Cook – considering the localised nature of the injury, the patient’s age and the fact that it was at C3/4 rather than C6/7 as is more commonly the case for natural cervical degereration – contended the symptoms to be more likely “post-traumatic than age-related”.

Read more…

Reproduced with the permission of Carter Capner Law

Related Posts

Recent Comments



    Discover more from David Cormack, Barrister

    Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

    Continue reading